The creatures, in search of more candy, decide to trick or treat at a haunted house they find at the end of the street. They hear a song coming from inside the house, so they decide to knock on the door. Upon entering, they see their friend the witch standing over a pot. She tells them she is making a potion using special ingredients. She starts to sing: “boiling hot, boiling hot, what shall we add to the witch’s pot?”. The werewolf replies: “boiling hot, boiling hot, we’ll add some spiders to the witch’s pot”. The ghost replies: “boiling hot, boiling hot, we’ll add some eyes to the witch’s pot”. The monster replies: “boiling hot, boiling hot, we’ll add a pumpkin to the witch’s pot”. The vampire replies: “boiling hot, boiling hot, we’ll add some snakes to the witch’s pot”. The witch adds a pumpkin, the final ingredient, to the pot. “The potion is finally ready!” the creatures gleefully exclaim.